Can you find Arthur's body in rdr2? If you read the first newspaper you can acquire, and it may be The Saint Dennis Times N 43, you can actually figure out more details on that Blackwater heist. [Spoiler Alert] In the epilogue there is a mission where you take revenge on Micah and in that mission you are told that Micah and Dutch have already gone back and retrieved the money from blackwater. It lies east of the Kamassa River and due west of Annesburg. N7twitch 1 yr. ago. Through his mother, he is a descendant of the Red Wolf Native Americans tribe, and one of the grandchildren of Running Moon, the tribes current chief. Reddit community for discussing and sharing content relating to Red Dead Redemption 2 & Red Dead Online. The dates possibly are 1835 to 1881, meaning she would have died about 18 years before the start of "Red Dead Redemption 2." John and Arthur manage to run through the caves, escape with their horses on the other side, and ride away until their horses are killed. Bill Williamson was 45 when John tracked him down to Nuevo Paraiso, and Micah Bell was 47 when hes killed by John and Dutch at Beechers Hope. Hope this helps! We get more details on ultimately what happened in that situation. he did not say a . If one looks a little closer at her grave, there's a quote that says: "There was grace in her steps. The links above will perform a search for the content that matches this page's name. No you cant. In the epilogue, the Murfree Brood move back into the cave and the location becomes a Gang Hideout that can occasionally be cleared for loot. We collect and tell stories of people from all around the world. The difference is that you fight back to the camp and head into the cave for the money. Im pretty sure the money that Micah refers to in the epilogue is the Blackwater money, which is not the same as the money in Dutchs chest in Beaver Hollow. Many plot developments occur during this mission, and during the conclusion, you will see a cutscene inside a cabin. After the mission is over, you'll be awarded an astonishing $20,000 as your cut. If you decide to help John, you will fight your way up the mountain with . In Red Dead Redemption micah and Dutch go back for it and in American venom micah says they got the money from black water and then some. Arthur and Sadie travel to Van Horn to free Abigail. Their are two savings boxes, the one that got destroyed was the one you personally donate to but the hidden one is what part of the missions cut goes to, which is the same money their supposed to be using to go to Tahiti while the one that was destroyed was the one used for camp upgrades, Wait, money?? Then start the mission: Our Best Selves in Beaver Hollow. All Legendary Fish Locations. 2. Please fill in your e-mail so we can share with you our top stories. This is demonstrated most when he abducted John Marstons family in order to strong-arm him into hunting the former members of the Van der Linde gang, changing the terms of their agreement in order to suit his needs, and subsequently betraying Marston, despite all he had done for Ross. How do you make someone with BPD feel better? Red Dead Redemption 2https://store.pla. How to remove construction in Dwarf Fortress. Man i wish i would have seen this yesterday, I wish Id known this before doing the Aberdeen farm. It's a site that collects all the most frequently asked questions and answers, so you don't have to spend hours on searching anywhere else. In the process, Tom ODriscoll killed Jake while Sadie took refuge in the cellar. John was therefore born in 1873 which makes him 26 in Red Dead Redemption 2 and 38 in Red Dead Redemption. Go back into the cave for money. How long can a goose egg stay on your head? The doctor hilariously starts smoking a pipe right next to Arthur, and sends him on his way after giving him a shot. So having a 1,000 dollar bounty on his head is actually one of the highest bounties you can achieve in the game. Authorities believe that the men must have stashed the cash in Blackwater before fleeing, and the town remains on high alert. Good Ending . https://www.google.com/search?q=can+john+marston+get+the+money+from+the+cave&oq=can+John+marston+get+the+&aqs=chrome.1.69i57j0i512l3j0i22i30l5.6639j0j7&client=ms-android-samsung-gn-rev1&sourceid=chrome-mobile&ie=UTF-8. While Arthur may have passed on, his work remains. I've played the whole game I just don't remember. You'll go quite deep, up a ladder . The games vast and atmospheric world will also provide the foundation for a brand new online multiplayer experience. If you choose to helpJohn, you will be taken to the top of a cliff . Now, you can also see a "Wanted" poster for Dutch at that very same location. Dont retrieve it, but leave it for John to pick up later. Because at one point at camp susan tells Arthur that someone had smashed the savings box. No matter what you do, Arthur Morgan dies. All Minigames Locations (Poker, Blackjack, Five Finger Fillet and Dominoes). She had hoped they'd kill Dutch, or at, least get his attention on hers. If you're already done or almost done with the story, then yes. After Beaver Hollow we never heard what hapened to the Dutch's chest ( gang money ) i know you can go back to get the money but Micah attack you and get the money before Arthur die and in the epilogue Micah had the Blackwater money but what hapened to the gang money ? Now, at some point before our started game in 1899, Dutch killed the brother of his one-time associate, Colm O'Driscoll, who, in return, took Annabelle's life. Along with John, Susan joins Arthur's side and points a shotgun at Micah, demanding that he puts his guns down. There you'll find a newspaper scrap that says: "May 1899 outlaw gang wanted over the heist. Wish I wouldve seen this sooner. The Blackwater heist's events shook Hosea's faith in Dutch, although he admits a bit later on in the story that their mission had been dead for a long time before this. But alas, rules are rules. Turns out, Molly was the one who betrayed all of you, getting Lenny and Hosea killed, and John captured. After leaving the gang, Tilly marries a lawyer from Haiti with the surname Pierre, who she would have a daughter with shortly afterwards. Word of the cave's entrance spread among the native people as well as among settlers who arrived later . Now, Dutch also mentions that he left his home when he was around 15-years-old because he rarely got along with his mother, whose death Dutch only found out several months from his uncle. It does not make sense, and we clearly know that he's a big part of the storyline in the first "Red Dead Redemption" game, but where does he go in the end? On the way out, you fight Micah in the burning remnants of the camp.J. Since Arthur was relatively young when he met Dutch, he thought that he had changed and even held out hope to his last breath that Dutch was still a good guy and would do the right thing. Red Dead Redemption 2 Optimized 60FPS Ultra Settings, Red Dead Redemption 2 How to Play Free Aim Lobbies (Red Dead Online), Red Dead Redemption 2 Solo Lobby Huckleberry Guide (Red Dead Online), Red Dead Redemption 2 All Jack Hall Gang Treasure Map Locations and Solutions, Red Dead Redemption 2 All Legendary Animal Locations. . Then start the mission: Our Best Selves in Beaver Hollow. The trail east of Beaver Hollow is one of the locations where random encounters can happen, including an ambush from Murfree Broods. All Minigames Locations (Poker, Blackjack, Five Finger Fillet and Dominoes). Lenny Summers In the southeastern part of Bluewater Marsh, under a small group of trees at the swamps. John and Sadie will open a chest, claiming a fortune in gold and money. However, it ended in disaster and forced the gang to flee into the Blizzard Lee mountains of Amerarino to escape the heat. Press J to jump to the feed. East-southeast near the trail junction is a dreamcatcher. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. The story of Red Dead Redemption 2 is one of failure. I thought in the "for Tahiti" chest was all the gang members FAITH. After silently killing a few of the Murfrees, the player is given the option to either flush out the others from the cave with dynamite, or to go into the cave and attack them directly. After a few missions in the epilogue, you will receive all of Arthur's . Bills age is confirmed in the official Game of the Year strategy guide for Red Dead Redemption, while Micahs age can be learned from an in-game newspaper in RDR2. When you play as John Marston, you will eventually come across a mission called American Venom, it's the last mission. If you choose to go back for the money as Arthur, Once he dies you see Micah picking up the money for himself in the bag. Dutch appears to be a broken man. After the epilogue the game has nearly ended and gang has been seperated sadie went on to carry out her life same as in gang i.e. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Is there a way for Arthur Morgan to not get tuberculosis? Micah, in his typical weasel fashion, tries to convince John to join . Help John to get to safety; If you go back for the money then go to Beaver Hollow. Awesome tip. Arthur told him that Micah was the rat, and Dutch refused to believe it because of his arrogance and pride. Do Men Still Wear Button Holes At Weddings? Can you get Dutchs money as John Marston? So this report confirms that he is still alive, and you can find him the last mission of the game, "American Venom," at Micah Bell's hideout at the top of Mount Hagen. Adler Ranch Barrow Lagoon Beartooth Beck Cairn Lake Cairn Lodge Calumet Ravine Cattail Pond Chez Porter Clawson's Rest Colter Cotorra Springs Deadboot Creek Dodd's Bluff Donner Falls Dormin Crest Ewing Basin Fairvale Shanty Flattened Cabin Glacier Granite Pass Grizzlies East Grizzlies West Lake Isabella Martha's Swain Micah's Hideout** Millesani Claim Moonstone Pond Mount Hagen Mysterious Hill Home O'Creagh's Run Planters Baun Spider Gorge Tempest Rim The Loft Three Sisters Wapiti Indian Reservation Whinyard Strait Window Rock Witches Cauldron Veteran's Homestead, Abandoned Trading Post Annesburg Bacchus Station Beaver Hollow Black Balsam Rise Brandywine Drop Butcher Creek Caliban's Seat Carmody Dell Castor's Ridge Chadwick Farm Citadel Rock Cornwall Kerosene & Tar Cumberland Falls Cumberland Forest Deer Cottage Doverhill Downes Ranch Elysian Pool Emerald Ranch Emerald Station Fire Lookout Tower Firwood Rise Flatneck Station Fort Brennand Fort Wallace Gill Landing Granger's Hoggery Guthrie Farm Hani's Bethel Heartland Oil Fields Heartland Overflow Horseshoe Overlook Huron Glen Larned Sod Limpany Lucky's Cabin MacLean's House Manito Glade Meteor House Mossy Flats Oil Derrick Osman Grove Reed Cottage Ridge View** Roanoke Ridge Roanoke Valley Six Point Cabin Sawbone Clearing The Heartlands Trading Post Twin Stack Pass Valentine Van Horn Mansion Van Horn Trading Post Willard's Rest, Aberdeen Pig Farm Argil Rise** Bayall Edge Bayou Nwa Bluewater Marsh Braithwaite Manor Bolger Glade Caliga Hall Canebreak Manor Catfish Jacksons Clemens Cove Clemens Point Compson's Stead Copperhead Landing Crawdad Willies Dewberry Creek Eris Field Face Rock Fishing Spot Hagen Orchards Hill Haven Ranch Houseboat Lagras Lakay Lonnie's Shack Macomb's End Mattock Pond Merkins Waller Old Greenbank Mill Old Harry Fen Old Trail Rise Pleasance Prinz & Co. Radley's House Radley's Pasture Rhodes Ringneck Creek Robard Farm Saint Denis Scarlett Meadows Shady Belle Siltwater Strand Sisika Penitentiary Southfield Flats Thtre Rleur Fontana Theatre The Grand Korrigan Trapper's Cabin, Appleseed Timber Company Aurora Basin Bear Claw Beecher's Hope Beryl's Dream Big Valley Black Bone Forest Blackwater Broken Tree Cochinay Diablo Ridge Evelyn Miller Camp Fort Riggs Great Plains Hanging Dog Ranch Hawks Eye Creek Lenora View Little Creek River Lone Mule Stead Manzanita Post Montana Ford Monto's Rest Mount Shann Nekoti Rock Old Tom's Blind Owanjila Owanjila Dam Painted Sky Pronghorn Ranch** Quaker's Cove Riggs Station Shepherds Rise** Stilt Shack Strawberry Swadbass Point Tall Trees Tanner's Reach Taxidermist House Valley View Vetter's Echo Wallace Overlook Wallace Station Watson's Cabin, Armadillo Benedict Pass Benedict Point Brittlebrush Trawl Cholla Springs Coot's Chapel Critchley's Ranch Cueva Seca Dixon Crossing Fort Mercer Gaptooth Breach Gaptooth Ridge Greenhollow Hamlin's Passing Hanging Rock Hennigan's Stead Jorge's Gap Lake Don Julio MacFarlane's Ranch Manteca Falls Mercer Station Mescalero Odd Fellow's Rest Old Bacchus Place Pike's Basin Plainview Pleasance House Rathskeller Fork Rattlesnake Hollow Repentance Ridgewood Farm Riley's Charge Ro Bravo Ro del Lobo Ro del Lobo Rock Scratching Post Silent Stead Solomon's Folly Stillwater Creek Thieves' Landing Tumbleweed Twin Rocks Two Crows Venter's Place Warthington Ranch, Aguasdulces Arroyo de la Vibora Baha de la Paz Cinco Torres El Nido La Capilla Manicato, Bacchus Bridge Bard's Crossing Dakota River Dixon Crossing Flat Iron Lake Kamassa River Lannahechee River Lower Montana River Manteca Falls Montana Ford Redemption Mountains San Luis River Sea of Coronado Upper Montana River. Epilogue. With Susan temporarily distracted by this, Micah takes his chance and shoots her, resulting in her death. The sequel, Red Dead Redemption 2, shows the aftermath of the botched robbery attempt by the Van der Linde gang, and youll spend almost the entirety of the game staying away from it, as youll be shot on sight. If Arthur goes back for the money and has high Honor, Micah is seen carrying all that money away with him. If he has low Honor, the sack is still on the ground but Micah seems to leave it, strangely. aft Home News While there's nothing stopping you from . It also serves as a gang hideout for the Murfree Brood, and as the location of the Van der Linde gang's camp site during the sixth chapter of the game. Progress up to a certain point, however, and the effects of Arthurs TB will still start to set in. The money is stored behind the mom painting directly at the front door. on rockpapershotgun.com, View If you finished the game with a high Honor rating, Arthurs grave will be adorned with flowers. No you can't. [Spoiler Alert] In the epilogue there is a mission where you take revenge on Micah and in that mission you are told that Micah and Dutch have already gone back and retrieved the money from blackwater. The trail east of Beaver Hollow is one of the locations where random encounters can happen, including an ambush from Murfree Broods. If you help John, you'll travel with him through cliffs and fight Pinkertons. Another ambush location is the small road that runs north of Beaver Hollow, which is less dangerous and only consists of a hanging corpse; regardless, players are advised to be careful when travelling along the main trail near camp. Feel free to tell us in the comments section below. Regarding the money, Dutch does not even bother with the stash; he just lets John take the remainder. The first antibiotic, penicillin, wasnt discovered until 1928. You dont go into the cave as marston getting the cash, you need to do some missions . So, the question is: "Where does Dutch go for those four years?". Press J to jump to the feed. The difference is that you fight back to the camp and head into the cave for the money. A few missions into the epilogue, John does inherit all of Arthur's outfits and . If you go for the money, it plays out largely the same. While theres nothing stopping you from checking out Blackwater during the rest of the game, its basically impossible to explore the town in your current state. Spoilers ahead, obviously. After chapter six, we dont actually see Dutch until the very end of epilogue two, although he can be read about in one of the newspaper reports. A small detail that many Red Dead Redemption 2 players likely missed shows that Dutch genuinely cares about Arthur Morgans well-being. But the character plays an even bigger part in Red Dead Redemption 2, getting his own arc that is filled with ups and downs.Naturally, because of his increased screen-time, you learn a lot more about the charismatic gang leader.. RELATED: Dutch's Best Quotes In Red Dead Redemption 2 He valued loyalty above everything else. Can you go back and get Dutch's money rdr2? On the way out, you fight Micah in the burning remnants of the camp. If visited while the Murfree Brood control it as a hideout, two different conversations can be heard depending on the entrance the player takes. Your email address will not be published. The games dialogue is still fresh in my head I 100 percented it and yet I still know most of the dialogue thats how good it is. In the finale, you have the option to go with John or go back to the camp to retrieve the money. Accept the drink, (or the food sample if it's your second . If not, Arthur would have the key on him when he died, but no one would know. And then on the train mission john tells Arthur that the money is hidden in the cave at beaver hollow and then he says so so much for hiding it hear camp. Pinkertons increase search". The second chest is the gangs savings, this is where the money obtained after completing missions is stored. Dutch's chest. This might indicate why he dislikes being in San Denis and Lemoine, which you'll find out when you reach the later chapters of the game. Dutch ended up killing a defenseless young woman named Heidi McCourt. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Dutch was first and foremost a very arrogant and prideful man that did not want to accept that he was wrong in any way. What happens if you go get the money instead of helping John? Arthur meets a 12 year old John Marston in 1885, through Dutch's rescue of the boy from a lynching after he had stolen from homesteaders. Arthur didnt need a diagnosis to tell him that he was going to die; even if he somehow escaped being shot or hanged, his death is an inevitability. EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Limited Or Anthology Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actress In A Comedy Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Supporting Actor In A Comedy Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actress In A Limited Or Anthology Series Or Movie, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actor In A Limited Or Anthology Series Or Movie. What happend to all blackwater money + Dutch's chest money Blackwater money is 150.000 dollar Dutchs chest is 42.000 (total 192.000) But we only get 20.000 + 1.500 debt pay off) if we say charles got 21.500, sadie got 21.500, What happend to other 127.500 dollar? All Grave Locations. One of them, Sadie Adler, became a fan favorite due to her character growth and relationship with Arthur. Choosing to help John Marston will trigger Red Dead Redemption 2 's Honorable and best ending. 1. I'm a little confused the money in Dutch's chest in the cave at beaver hollow is the gangs savings right? Just like in the first Red Dead Redemption, prostitution will definitely be a part of the world, but it wont be a part that you can utilize. (SPOILER) Dutch's chest remains in Beaver Hollow if you chose the honorful option. Home Layout 3NewsTechnology All CodingHosting Create Device Mockups Browser with DeviceMock Creating Local Server From Public Address Professional Gaming Can Build Career CSS Properties You Should Know The Psychology Price. Wind Cave is a culturally significant and sacred site to the Lakota and Cheyenne, and to many other tribes that traveled in and around the area that would become Wind Cave National Park. 1/23/2021 in General. The only people who were truly shaken by her death were Karen Jones and Mary-Beth Gaskill. After John Marston finishes off Micah the game's main narrative ends for real, but there is still plenty to do in the wild west. Dutch is the only one who is supposed to know The location of the gang savings chest, he always hides it close by whenever the move camps. It's hard to deny just how large a role Dutch Van Der Linde plays in the first Red Dead Redemption. The money from Blackwater is the money John uses to pay off the debts for Beecher's hope. Inside the cave in the western chamber is jewelry, money, and Valerian Root. Momentarily afterwards, Javier Escuella arrives, to tell them that Pinkertons are coming. If you don't want spoilers don't read any further. Back in the mission ", Inside the cave in the western chamber is jewelry, money, and, East-southeast near the trail junction is a. the cash box is the camp money for day to day things while Dutch's chest is the big "live free" savings that he normally hides near camp. For example: The caves are the home of the Murfree Brood, an inbred family of cruel killers and rapists; The overall atmosphere of the camp is very gloomy as they are constantly under the shade of trees, compared to the more open areas of the previous campsites; Many members who once got along well with their comrades no longer trust them; The flaps to Dutch's tent will be closed as opposed to his tent in previous chapters being open and inviting, with Dutch himself usually being alone in the tent or the cave; The inability to perform chores or restock Medicine and Ammo shows the defeatist attitude among the gang; Table games are no longer available to play asthe overall camp mood deteriorates; There is the sound of wind blowing through the trees, highlighting the somber tone; Some of the horses are grouped very closely together and don't have much room to walk around, making even the horses uneasy. Chapter 6, which takes place in Beaver Hollow, is the longest chapter in the game. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Matthews is a con artist who tried to rob Dutch, and funny enough, Dutch had the same intentions. View Anyone doing another playthrough could use this including myself! Before any more can be said, Susan Grimshaw shoots Molly in the stomach with a shotgun, killing her instantly. The only person who found his body was Charles, but he wouldnt have known where the chest was. There isn't a lot of information known on Heidi McCourt. It's great to see the varying views of these characters. All Poisonous Trail Treasure Map Locations and [], Other Guides: Cheat Codes! Did you know about his history? What Happens If You Return To Dutch's Money Cave After Beating Red Dead Redemption 2? Soon after Arthur returns to Beaver Hollow, Molly O'Shea arrives at the scene. As is the case with all former camp locations, visiting Beaver Hollow after achieving 100% story completion will result in. Arthur tries . The small one by Dutch's tent (that Susan tells you was smashed) is more so like Petty cash for food, supplies, upgrades, etc. This troubled childhood actually causes Dutch to form his own gang after befriending Hosea Matthews. Now that's where you are able to get the best or worst endings depending on your Honor System. The gang slowly unite behind Dutch and Micah, pointing their guns at Arthur and John, but before either of them can be killed, Pinkertons assault the camp, resulting in Dutch and the others fleeing. Either way, the Murfrees are defeated, and the duo come across a girl named Meredith, who had been taken from the stagecoach a few days prior and imprisoned in the cave, after which she was subjected to sexual abuse. The one where you have to find Magnifico in the woods. But there's a way to get Arthur's money back. In the end, Dutch was at a loss for words, possibly because he realized working with Micah was a bad choice, but we end up seeing him save both John and Sadie's life by shooting Micah, then mysteriously walks away. Most of the gang members believed Molly got what she deserved. Now, not much is known about his younger days, but he seemed to have developed a grudge against Southerners because of his father's death. Also the amount of money in chest is part of that great rockstar logic.. lol Just like when you leave Arthur's money at the pig farm and john gets it 8 years later and none of . Accept the drink, (or the food sample if its your second visit) and find yourself in the mud pit with zero money. Red Dead Redemption 2 When Does the Game Unlock on PC? 1.4) Can you find Dutch money? After Beaver Hollow we never heard what hapened to the Dutch's chest ( gang money ) i know you can go back to get the money but Micah attack you and get the money before Arthur die and in the epilogue Micah had the Blackwater money but what hapened to the gang money ? If you remember, the way money is split up is half of the total . The gang slowly unite behind Dutch and Micah, pointing their guns at Arthur and John, but before either of them can be killed, Pinkertons assault the camp, resulting in Dutch and the others fleeing. I went to Beaver Hollow cave after Red dead redemption 2 ending and found dutch money box. But theres a way to get Arthurs money back. All Jack Hall Gang Treasure Map Locations and Solutions. Red is the only known son of Nate Harlow, a gold miner, and his wife Falling Star. The money is stored behind the mom painting directly at the front door. Im reading this literally right after Arthur dies lmao, whoops. Can mental illness make you lose custody? In fact, she's never seen during "Red Dead Redemption 2," even though she's mentioned numerous times throughout the game. So, take some notes because this will enhance your gameplay and perhaps clear a few things up. Can you finish Arthur's side missions as John. After returning from Guarma and being attacked by Pinkertons at Lakay, Dutch sends Arthur Morgan and Charles Smith north to find somewhere suitable for a new camp. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Which Teeth Are Normally Considered Anodontia. /r/RedDeadRedemption - A subreddit dedicated to Red Dead Redemption & Red Dead Redemption 2, developed by Rockstar Games, the creators behind the Grand Theft Auto series. If so, John makes no mention of going back for it. Arthur and Micah's duel results in a draw that ends with Dutch and Micah heading off into the sunset. Stop playing story missions before Arthur dies, and hell keep on yee-hawing for as long as the player desires. You can check that out in the Notorious Bad Man Alive article. While Arthur gives John his satchel with his belongings in it, it doesn't contain all of his money. Make sure you finished the mission: My Last Boy (the death of Eagle Flies). AmoMama creates engaging, meaningful content for women. Hoseas grave is by Lennys. There are no pictures or last name or hints about who she is, and you don't even see her in the game. Can you get the gang's money as John rdr2? An early cave tour from the 1890s led by John Stabler. 1.1) Can you get Dutch's money in the cave as John? The pair arrive at Beaver Hollow, where they come across a stagecoach from Annesburg that had reportedly disappeared without a trace. As tensions continue to rise, John Marston arrives, still wounded from the recent train robbery, claiming that Dutch left him to die. If Arthur had high honor when he died, then players will find the grave adorned with flowers and in pristine shape. The pair got married in 1896 and tried to make a life for themselves on a ranch in Ambarino. Micah tells Dutch "she's just a girl" and they need to ride off with the money they got. Rdr2 bad ending involves you going out for money by going back to the camp. Arthur takes her back to her mother in Annesburg, while Charles goes back to the rest of the gang to direct them to their new camp. All Poisonous [], Other RDR2 Guides: All Legendary Animal Locations. What Happens If You Return To Dutch's Money Cave After Beating Red Dead Redemption 2? After you've killed Micah, Sadie tells J. Can you get the Blackwater money as John? Throughout the game, we see our two main characters John and Arthur, have entirely different views on Dutch. Abigail has been captured by the Pinkertons and John is presumed dead. Can you get Dutchs money in the cave as John? Red Dead Redemption mission is a goodbye to Arthur.